Discover how contemplative prayer and meditation share one purpose—inner stillness and divine union across faiths.
Introduction: The Modern Spiritual Dilemma
Many spiritual seekers today, especially in the West, ask a simple but profound question: “Am I betraying my faith if I meditate?” Raised in traditions of prayer, they encounter Eastern meditation and feel both curiosity and guilt. Are these practices competing paths—or parallel ways to the same divine encounter?
After studying the great teachers of both traditions—from the Christian mystics like Teresa of Ávila and John Main to the yogic masters who spoke of Dhyana—I’ve come to believe the answer is simpler and more beautiful: they are two languages describing one experience—the stillness where the soul meets the Divine.
 |
| contemplative prayer vs meditation |
Defining the Practices: What Are We Actually Talking About?
Meditation
Across the Eastern spiritual traditions—especially Yoga and Buddhism—meditation (Dhyana) is a disciplined inward turning of attention. It trains awareness to rest beyond thoughts, sensations, and desires, revealing an inner stillness that is always present. The yogic texts call this “union with the Self”—a state where observer and observed dissolve into one flow of consciousness.
Contemplative Prayer
In the Christian mystical lineage, contemplation is not thinking about God—it is resting in God. As St. Teresa of Ávila described, it is “a close sharing between friends.” The Catechism of the Catholic Church defines contemplative prayer as “a gaze of faith fixed on Jesus… a silent love.”
Meditation engages the mind to seek understanding; contemplation surrenders the mind to experience love. One seeks to know God, the other to be with God.
 |
| Christian mysticism explained |
The Core Difference: Intention vs. Attention
If we look beneath form, the essential distinction is this:
Meditation (Attention): The practitioner intentionally trains awareness—to watch the breath, repeat a mantra, or observe thoughts without attachment. Its movement is from chaos to clarity.
Contemplative Prayer (Intention): The focus is relational. The soul opens to the presence of God through silence, surrender, and love. Its movement is from self toward communion.
Yet both practices, as Thomas Keating observed, aim at the same destination: resting in God. Whether through mantra (as in John Main’s “Maranatha”) or silent consent (as in Centering Prayer), both dissolve the boundaries between self and the Divine Presence.
The Bridge: Where the Paths Converge
This is where theology and experience meet.
Both contemplative prayer and meditation involve the same inner dynamics:
Silence and Stillness: In both, the chatter of the mind quiets, and awareness deepens into presence.
Breath and Attention: Yogic breathing (pranayama) and Christian centering both use the breath as an anchor for the soul.
Surrender of Ego: Buddhist anatta (no-self) and Christian kenosis (self-emptying) describe the same spiritual movement—letting go of self-centeredness to encounter divine fullness.
As Dr. David Benner writes, the “emptying” of meditation and the “filling” of prayer are not opposites—they are the same moment viewed from two perspectives. In stillness, the self dissolves, and the Divine fills the heart.
Mystics across traditions affirm this union. Meister Eckhart called it “the birth of God in the soul.” The yogis call it “samadhi.” Both point to the same reality: union beyond words.
A Practical Guide: How to Practice Both
1. Practicing Meditation (Dhyana)
Sit upright and comfortable, either on a chair or cushion.
Close your eyes and focus on your breath.
Observe thoughts arise and pass without judgment.
If distracted, gently return attention to your breath or a sacred word (like peace or Maranatha).
Continue for 10–15 minutes, allowing silence to expand.
2. Practicing Contemplative Prayer
Choose a quiet space and a simple sacred word (e.g., love, Jesus, Abba).
Intend to be in God’s presence, not to think about Him.
When thoughts arise, return gently to your sacred word—not as repetition but as relationship.
Rest in stillness for 20 minutes, twice daily if possible.
Together, these two practices become the rhythm of breathing in and out—meditation as listening, prayer as loving.
 |
| yoga to deepen prayer |
FAQ: Your Biggest Questions Answered
Q1: Can I use yoga to deepen my prayer?
Yes. Yoga postures and breathwork can prepare the body for stillness, making it easier to rest in prayerful awareness. The body becomes an ally rather than a distraction.
Q2: Is it wrong for Christians to meditate?
No. As Dom John Main taught, Christian meditation is rooted in silence and Scripture. Meditation is not a religion—it’s a practice of presence.
Q3: Is Dhyana the same as contemplative prayer?
They share the same inner aim—stilling the mind and opening the heart to Divine union—but differ in language and symbols. Dhyana emphasizes awareness; contemplation emphasizes relationship.
Q4: What if I can’t quiet my mind?
Don’t fight your thoughts. In both paths, the goal is not silence itself, but surrender to the silence already present.
 |
| how to practice contemplative prayer and meditation together |
Conclusion: One Silence, Many Names
Meditation and contemplative prayer are not opposing roads but two expressions of the same longing—the human yearning to rest in what is eternal.
The mystics of both East and West whisper the same truth: “Be still, and know that I am.”
In that stillness, labels fade, doctrines soften, and only love remains.
COMMENTS